by Aqui Griffin, 11/10/24
As atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) levels continue to rise, understanding the impacts on plant life becomes increasingly crucial. In Part 1 of this post we learned about the science behind the different ways plants fix carbon, and how they are responding to increased atmospheric CO2 and climate change. Building on this, we now turn our attention to sustainable approaches that can help us through the next century and feed future generations. We will learn about innovative strategies utilizing what we just learned, that not only address the challenges posed by changing environmental conditions but also tackle the issues inherent in modern agricultural practices. By bridging the gap between scientific understanding and practical application, we aim to uncover solutions that can enhance food security while promoting environmental stewardship.
In this section, we'll explore strategies including agroforestry, intercropping, conservation agriculture, and crop breeding. These approaches aim to improve crop resilience while promoting sustainability and biodiversity in our food systems.
A farmer harvests agave amongst native mesquite, using traditional tools
Carbon sequestration and Intercropping: Strategically integrating the uniquely adapted CAM and C4 plants in an intercropping system can dramatically increase productivity. This approach holds a lot of promise not only by promoting regeneration, but also bringing social economic benefits. The Billion Agave Project in the highlands of Mexico is a perfect example of this type of adaptation, where farmers are densely planting agave (CAM plant) amongst established and newly planted mesquite (drought resistant C3 plant), along with a rotational livestock grazing system. Mesquite have deep root systems with good evidence of nitrogen fixation, while agave are powerful CO2 sinks that require no additional inputs. In addition the agave is used as a feedstock, after a 30-day fermentation, and at maturity is harvested to make mescal.
Microclimate management: Integrating trees into agricultural landscapes not only increase carbon storage and soil health, but moderates temperature extremes and reduces water stress on crops through microclimates. This can be applied in dry, hot environments, but also in areas receiving too much rainfall. It is important to consider optimal tree cover in trade-off theory to balance transpiration and soil moisture retention.
As an example of using trees in heavy rainfall areas, we can learn from the indigenous peoples of Northern Thailand. We caught up with the owner of Akha Ama Coffee, Lee Ayu Chuepa, about the challenges of climate change the small coffee bean farmers are facing. He spoke about how the villagers are using traditional knowledge and a deep understanding of the local ecology to preemptively plant native trees amongst the coffee to combat the anticipated rainfall of this year's La Niña. This strategy takes advantage of the fact that younger trees, for at least the first 20 years, send out deep tap roots and can uptake excess water more efficiently while the canopy offers protection from intense rain for the precious coffee plants beneath.
Biodiversity enhancement: Combining both of these strategies by integrating native trees and intercropping CAM and C4 plants, promotes biodiversity. The diverse ecosystems that are created are better at managing perturbations and can increase productivity in areas that have previously been degraded. This is a well observed behavior in forests and in gardens. It should be stressed that we must be careful in selecting the varieties that match our climates and ecosystems. In certain environments, introducing the wrong species can have devastating effects on the local flora and fauna. This is why researching prohibited or invasive species before planting is absolutely necessary.
Conservation Agriculture builds on the strategy of increasing biodiversity to help build natural resilience to changes in the climate. Many of these practices are common knowledge in the alternative agriculture communities. However, we mention them here because they are some of the most cost-effective methods that are quick and easy to implement. Some examples include:
Minimal tillage: Reduce soil disturbance to preserve soil structure and organic matter. This was mentioned previously, research indicates soil biodiversity can aid in plant resilience not only through increased water capacity in topsoil, but also influencing plant adaptation to different stressors.
Crop rotation: Implement diverse crop rotations to improve soil health and break pest cycles. Increased CO2 and temperatures can increase pests occurrence. This is because decreased nutritional content in plants, may require insects and pests to consume more to meet dietary needs and/or the plants become less able to deter attacks. A minimum 3-year crop rotation has been shown to help decrease impacts.
Cover cropping: Use cover crops to protect soil, fix nitrogen, and increase organic matter. This method not only promotes biodiversity which conveys benefits as discussed previously, but also helps hold moisture in the ground as higher temperatures will increase the need for more water in certain environments.
Wild variety conservation: Keep conservation gardens with dedicated spaces to wild flora and fauna, or protect areas already populated by wild species. If your areas depend on livestock, make sure to develop rotational grazing plans with your community to reduce soil degradation. These habitats can be used to maintain wild cultivars to be used for future resilient plant selection and breeding.
Creating new plant varieties, may immediately draw your mind to think about GMOs or CRISPR, but in actuality humans have been doing this for at least 11,000 years, starting with the domestication of plants at the beginning of sedentary agriculture. Many different methods of working with plants exist that produce new desirable traits without relying on genetic modification. The main methods we discuss here are selection, conventional breeding, and less mentioned, de-domestication or feralization.
Selection: Plant selection is a simple process where we choose to propagate a plant based on traits we find desirable. For much of our history, we have been doing this to select for sweeter fruit, larger produce, healthier seeds, and overall productivity. This process has led to domesticated crops that produce high yields as a community, but perform poorly as individuals. Along with this, many have lost their resilience to stressors like pests, heat, and drought. On the other hand, wild species, tend to have all the later qualities of resilience but less productive in a community. This is likely because domesticated plants have evolved to grow in large fields with the same species, where determinate growth patterns were favored due to crowding.
Relationship between overall productivity of wild vs. domestic plants
So what is needed is to flip our domestic traits back to their wild counterparts, or more likely somewhere in between. If we look at the traits of wild species we see things we can start selecting on domestic species that should yield better resilience. Those traits include:
Natural seed dispersal mechanisms (Example: when the seed pod opens freely after a period of drying on the plant )
Higher secondary metabolite content (often bitter compounds)
Smaller but more numerous fruits/seeds
Indeterminate growth patterns
Higher fiber content
Variable dormancy periods (Is flowering happening earlier?)
Propagating after selection can be as simple as implementing a seed saving program or developing a more sophisticated breeding program.
Conventional Breeding: This leads us to the next method of conventional plant breeding. Traditional breeding has shown promise with the cultivation of several hybrid cultivars that demonstrate drought tolerance and disease resistance. Although some may question the effects of hybrids on our health and ecosystems, cross-pollination is a natural occurrence and plays a significant role in maintaining biodiversity. There is quite a lot that goes into creating a successful hybrid, and for the average person it is unlikely these methods will be worthwhile in pursuing. However, some advances are enabling higher success rates. One such method is inbreeding the parent through self-pollination. The donor traits are then more likely to be conferred to the offspring when cross-pollinating with the other parent. The usual process of breeding from the F1 hybrid continues, with backcrossing the donor as needed. This method, although proven, often takes a long time, 5-30 years, and at the rate we are seeing the climate change this may not be a fast enough solution for developing more resilient plant varieties.
De-domestication: A somewhat untapped approach is de-domestication, or feralization. This simply means a crop plant that has escaped cultivation and began persisting without human interference. This process has been of study for quite sometime but was mainly focused on understanding how GMOs might transfer traits to wild neighbors or vice-versa. Obviously it was an interest of many GMO patent owners to avoid contamination of their "property", and mutually environmentalists who didn't want a hybrid suddenly to gain super powers collapsing entire food chains. However, newer studies indicate that feralization can occur naturally, and so investigating more species is now under way. From the initial findings we understand that hybrids often occur on the margins of agricultural areas, and that although more pest and disease resistant, they also tend to lower the yields of the primary crops significantly when farmers are unable to be discerning during harvests. Quite often though we find them in our gardens as "volunteers". In Southeast Asia where we live, it is common to find chilis and different species of eggplant, popping up all over, usually in disturbed soil, and to never have been planted by humans. However, due to the sheer amount of small gardens that plant domesticated chilis and eggplants intentionally, it is safe to assume these plants are not necessarily wild. Their occurrence is so regular in fact that we can start to recognize the possession of wild traits previously discussed. Sometimes the plants continue propagation via birds, or humans, or both, which shows the continuous back and forth of selection from natural vectors and people.
Feralization is a promising approach to creating resilient plants, but caution should be exercised. Without comprehensive understanding of de-domestication, concern for creating invasive species is a risk. In fact one of the biggest invasive problems in the US today is with a feral hybrid boar that has destroyed many ecosystems and is hardly coming under control. In the tropics where biodiversity is much higher, the issue of introducing uncontrollable hybrids is less of a concern, although the chance does exist. This hasn't stopped scientists from entertaining the use of genetic editing though, a topic we will discuss a little later. Instead we will outline what we feel are more ecologically balanced approaches:
Selection - Choose varieties that may be more likely to survive. Some visual indicators may be smaller seeds, leaves, fruits, and early flowering. Choose plants that are perennial and/or self-pollinating, and able to be direct sowed. Avoid planting species that may have a wild ancestor already in the environment. If a hybrid outcompetes the ancestor, we may irreversibly lose genetic diversity that holds the key to adaptation at a later date.
Location - Based on historical evidence, feralization often occurs at the margins, so we should plant species at the intersections of wild and cultivated areas. Furthermore, it has been indicated that feral plants are highly correlated with disturbed soils, so we may consider planting in areas that we are just starting to rest, or leave fallow, in a rotational system.
Timing - One of the aspects of feral plants that should be obvious is to avoid interacting and disturbing them as much as possible. Even if working with crop plants with wild-type traits that can help it thrive on its own, we need to make sure to plant at the appropriate times. This includes planting at the start of rainy season to make sure the plant can establish on its own.
Adapt our Eating - Although not really a planting method, being adaptive with ones eating habits will help balance the traits in a species we are trying to de-domesticate. As mentioned earlier, bitterness is a trait often indicative of wild plants. So we may need to sacrifice taste preferences to maintain resilience in the plant. Also being aware of possible toxins that may be present in any particular plant genus or species can help prevent unintentional poisoning. Traditional knowledge can readily be applied here, since many indigenous peoples have developed menus and cooking methods to be able to consume many species that contain toxins. A good example of this is the Indigenous Amazonians complex process for detoxing cassava.
While genetic modification has the potential to create crops more resistant to climate stresses, it comes with several issues:
Ecological risks: Potential for unintended gene flow to wild relatives, affecting biodiversity.
Socioeconomic concerns: Concentration of seed ownership in a few large corporations, potentially disadvantaging small farmers.
Regulatory challenges: Varying global regulations create trade complications and ethical debates.
Unknown long-term effects: Potential unforeseen consequences on human health and ecosystems.
Instead of relying heavily on GMOs, a more sustainable approach focuses on enhancing genetic diversity through traditional breeding techniques and preserving heirloom varieties adapted to local conditions.
NOTE: Gene Edited (GEd) has been gaining adoption over more controversial methods of creating GMOs. It promises to be a precise tool without risks of introducing instability or unwanted effects. However, even if this is proven to be true, the use of GEd plants will only work to maintain or further increase expansion of monocultures and land degradation. In fact, many of the GEd plants being adopted by countries that have banned other GMOs, are intended as livestock feed. This does little more than continue to prop up the very unsustainable livestock industry significantly contributing to overall green house gas emissions.
Attempting to maximize production of CO2-responsive crops could lead to increased monocultures, which are problematic due to:
Reduced biodiversity: Simplification of agricultural landscapes harms wildlife and reduces ecosystem services.
Increased vulnerability: Monocultures are more susceptible to pests and diseases.
Soil degradation: Continuous cultivation of a single crop can deplete soil nutrients and structure.
Sustainable approaches promote crop diversity, rotations, and integration of natural habitats within agricultural landscapes.
Some farmers might respond to climate stress by increasing the use of fertilizers and pesticides, which is problematic because:
Environmental pollution: Runoff leads to water pollution and ecosystem damage.
Soil degradation: Overuse of chemicals can harm soil microbiomes and structure.
Greenhouse gas emissions: Nitrogen fertilizers are a significant source of nitrous oxide, a potent greenhouse gas.
Sustainable alternatives include integrated pest management, use of organic fertilizers, and practices that enhance natural soil fertility.
Sustainable agricultural practices offer the most promising path forward in addressing climate change and rising atmospheric CO2. These approaches adapt to changing conditions while also sequestering carbon and reducing emissions. In contrast to short-term technological fixes, sustainable agriculture focuses on working with natural systems, providing a resilient and ethical framework for feeding a growing global population in an uncertain climatic future.
As research progresses on plant responses to elevated CO2 and climate changes, it's crucial to apply this knowledge to promote ecological balance, support biodiversity, and ensure long-term agricultural viability. By prioritizing sustainable practices, we can create a more food-secure world for future generations while mitigating the impacts of climate change.